Skip to content

Civilization #02: Religion and the Dawn of Society

📺 Watch Lecture on YouTube: Civilization #2: Religion and the Dawn of Society

Core Thesis: The Cognitive Spark of Homo Religiosus, Cave Cathedrals, and Durkheimian Sacred Bonds

In this second lecture of The Story of "Civilization", Prof. Jiang Xueqin explores the deepest roots of human consciousness, asking a foundational civilizational question: What truly makes human beings distinct from all other animals?

Modern intellectual culture routinely categorizes human beings through two dominant frameworks:

  • The Economic Animal (Karl Marx): Human behavior is driven entirely by material scarcity, productive forces, and the pursuit of financial accumulation.
  • The Biological Animal (Charles Darwin): Human behavior is governed by evolutionary biology, reproductive competition, and the instinct to propagate genetic material.

Prof. Jiang challenges the exclusivity of both models. While acknowledging the undeniable importance of economics and biology, he demonstrates that humanity is first and foremost Homo religiosus—a religious creature. Tens of thousands of years before the invention of agriculture, cities, writing, or currency, Upper Paleolithic humans navigated their harsh Ice Age world through an intensely symbolic, animist cosmology. Religion is not an artificial tool invented by Bronze Age elites to subjugate peasants; it is the primary cognitive mechanism through which the human mind constructs meaning, connects with the living cosmos, and binds solitary individuals into an enduring moral society. Without religion, human society could never have emerged.

Drawing upon Ice Age subterranean cave sanctuaries (dating back 30,000 to 40,000 years), ancient burials of disabled individuals, the discovery of 32 recurring geometric symbols documented by Genevieve von Petzinger, the epistemological philosophy of Immanuel Kant, and the foundational sociological framework of Émile Durkheim, Prof. Jiang reveals how early humanity used ritual, acoustic resonance, and animist kinship to weave the sacred fabric of civilization.

graph TD
    subgraph ModernReductiveModels["Modern Materialist Models"]
        M1["Karl Marx: The Economic Animal<br/>(Driven by material accumulation & financial gain)"]
        M2["Charles Darwin: The Biological Animal<br/>(Driven by genetic propagation & reproductive fitness)"]
    end

    subgraph DeepHumanReality["The Foundational Human Reality"]
        HR["Homo Religiosus: The Religious Animal<br/>(Innate cognitive hunger for meaning, cosmic communion & sacred community)"]
    end

    M1 -.->|Interplay| HR
    M2 -.->|Interplay| HR
    HR ==>|Generates| Soc["Creation of Human Society & Collective Consciousness"]

1. The Ice Age Crucible: Scarcity and the Global Diaspora

To understand the emergence of Upper Paleolithic religion, one must grasp the severe environmental pressures of deep human history:

  • The Freezing Planet: For over ninety-five percent of Homo sapiens history, the Earth was locked in the bitter cold of the Last Glacial Maximum. The temperate, warm climate that made agriculture viable only stabilized approximately 12,000 years ago.
  • Out of Africa (c. 100,000 BP): Anatomically modern humans emerged in Africa roughly 300,000 years ago. Driven by climatic shifts and acute resource scarcity, human bands migrated out of Africa approximately 100,000 years ago, colonizing Europe, Asia, navigating to Australia, and crossing the frozen Bering Strait into the Americas.
  • A Tiny, Dispersed Population: Despite colonizing the entire planet, the global human population 20,000 years ago numbered only around one million people, scattered in small, highly mobile bands of 20 to 50 individuals.
  • Hominin Encounters: Early modern humans encountered and interbred with other archaic human species, including Neanderthals and Denisovans, until Homo sapiens became the sole surviving hominin.
  • In this perilous Ice Age environment, physical survival required far more than spears; it demanded profound psychological resilience, mutual trust, and shared cosmological frameworks to overcome terror and despair.

2. Subterranean Cathedrals: The Architecture of Paleolithic Cave Art

Between 40,000 and 15,000 years ago, Upper Paleolithic humans ventured into subterranean limestone caverns across Western Europe—such as Chauvet (c. 30,000 BCE), Lascaux (c. 20,000 BCE), and Altamira (c. 34,000 BCE)—to produce monumental art of astonishing artistic sophistication.

When modern master Pablo Picasso visited the painted cave of Altamira, he famously emerged in awe and remarked: "In 10,000 years, we have learned nothing." Artistically and cognitively, Ice Age humans were fully our equals.

Prof. Jiang investigates three core questions surrounding these cave paintings:

A. How Were They Painted?

  • Pigments: Early artists utilized natural mineral pigments: red ochre (iron oxide clay) and black charcoal from burnt wood.
  • Lighting: In pitch-black subterranean chambers where no sunlight penetrates, artists illuminated rock surfaces by burning animal fat in carved stone lamps or torches.

B. Why Did They Paint in the Deepest Chambers?

Early humans never lived inside deep caves. Caves were damp, cold, oxygen-poor, and dangerous. Domestic campsites were established outside beneath rock shelters or in portable skin tents.

  • Artists deliberately journeyed hundreds of meters into the deepest, most suffocating subterranean recesses to paint.
  • The Acoustic Revelation: Modern archaeological research reveals that cave paintings are concentrated precisely at the exact subterranean locations with the greatest acoustic resonance and sound reverberation.
  • Paleolithic caves were humanity's first sacred cathedrals. Accompanied by carved bone flutes, percussion, and rhythmic chanting, shamans conducted sacred ceremonial festivals where flickering torchlight made painted animal spirits appear to move and vibrate across the undulating stone walls.

C. What Did the Paintings Represent?

Cave walls do not depict an economic ledger of daily meals. Paleolithic trash middens show that foragers primarily consumed reindeer, small game, and fish. Yet reindeer are rarely painted.

  • Instead, artists rendered the most majestic, dangerous apex animals: cave lions, woolly rhinoceroses, mammoths, wild horses, and giant bison.
  • The animals are frequently depicted without visual separation—lions, horses, and rhinos sweeping together across the stone—representing nature as one unified, interconnected cosmic tapestry.
graph LR
    DeepCave["Deep Pitch-Black Cavern<br/>(Sensory Deprivation)"] --> Torchlight["Flickering Animal Fat Lamps<br/>(Altered Visual Perception)"]
    Torchlight --> Acoustics["Acoustic Resonance & Bone Flutes<br/>(Auditory Reverberation)"]
    Acoustics --> ShamanicRitual["Shamanic Chanting & Trance<br/>(Spirits Come Alive on Stone)"]
    ShamanicRitual --> CosmicCommunion["Sacred Communion with Animal Spirits"]

3. The Four Primal Mysteries of Paleolithic Consciousness

Because early humans possessed no written language, modern observers must use informed imagination to reconstruct their worldview. Prof. Jiang asks: If we were stripped of modern science and biology and placed in a freezing Ice Age landscape, what phenomena would fill us with wonder, terror, and awe?

Primal Natural Mystery Daily Human Experience & Observation Cosmological & Metaphysical Interpretation
1. The Mystery of Childbirth Witnessing a new living conscious human emerge miraculously from a woman's body without biological understanding. Formulated the universal veneration of the Mother Goddess / Divine Feminine; life originates from a cosmic, maternal womb.
2. The Mystery of the Celestial Sky Staring into pitch-black, unpolluted night skies glowing with countless stars, constellations, and moon cycles. Realized that our terrestrial world is only one of many cosmic realms; stars were perceived as ancestral souls or celestial spirits.
3. The Mystery of Physical Healing Watching a sick, feverish, or wounded body naturally recover and return from the edge of death. Mind-body dualism: health reflects alignment between the physical flesh and the immortal spirit; disharmony causes disease.
4. The Mystery of Living Nature Experiencing the vastness of forests, seasonal migrations of animals, and changing river currents. Animism: every tree, animal, river, and mountain possesses a living soul; humanity is an equal member of an interconnected cosmic family.

The Cosmic Symmetry of Wombs and Graves

Prof. Jiang outlines the ancient metaphysical logic connecting birth, death, and caves:

  • The Mother's Womb as Cosmic Portal: Life emerges out of darkness through the maternal womb, which acts as a sacred portal bringing a soul from the spirit world into physical reality.
  • The Earth as Symmetrical Portal: When an individual dies, the tribe buries the body back into the dark womb of Mother Earth, returning the departed soul to the spirit realm.
  • Caves as Nature's Womb: Deep limestone caverns were recognized as the sacred wombs of Mother Nature herself—natural portals connecting human existence with the transcendent animal and ancestral worlds.
graph LR
    SpiritWorld["The Spirit World / Celestial Realm"] -->|Maternal Womb (Portal of Birth)| EarthlyLife["Physical Human Life on Earth"]
    EarthlyLife -->|Earth Burial (Portal of Death)| SpiritWorld
    CaveSanctuary["Deep Subterranean Cave<br/>(Nature's Womb / Cosmic Portal)"] -.->|Ritual Communion| SpiritWorld

4. Animism: Kinship, Reciprocity, and the Living Forest

The primary religious worldview of Paleolithic humanity was Animism—the belief that every living entity in the natural world possesses an immortal soul (anima):

  • Humans, trees, animals, and rivers are all children of the same Mother Nature, existing as moral equals.
  • Humans do not hold dominion over nature; they belong to nature.

Modern Botanical Validation: The Living Forest

Prof. Jiang connects this ancient animist intuition to groundbreaking modern forest ecology:

  • Modern scientists have proven that trees in a forest communicate and share resources through vast subterranean fungal networks (mycorrhizae).
  • If a tree is deficient in water or nitrogen, neighboring trees pump nutrients through the fungal network to sustain it.
  • If pests or insects attack a tree, it sends biochemical warning signals through the network, prompting neighboring trees to produce defensive enzymes.
  • "Mother trees" actively recognize their own offspring, sending them vital sugars and moisture.
  • Paleolithic foragers lacked modern laboratory instruments, but through daily, intimate immersion in the forest, they intuitively recognized that nature functions as one vast, living, sentient organism.

The Moral Logic of Hunting: Asking Forgiveness

Animism generated an acute moral dilemma: If animals are our brothers and sisters with living souls, what gives humans permission to kill them?

  • Mother Nature requires balance and harmony: humans must eat to survive, and predators prevent prey overpopulation.
  • However, taking an animal's life disrupts cosmic balance. Therefore, hunters were morally obligated to:
  • Ask the animal's spirit for forgiveness before and after the hunt.
  • Pay ceremonial tribute to the slain animal's spirit.
  • Journey into deep cave sanctuaries to summon the animal's soul back into the spirit world, ensuring it would be reborn and return to provide meat for future generations.

5. Shamans, Therianthropes, and Reverence for Atypical Individuals

A. Shamans and Animal Disguise

To mediate between human bands and the unseen forces of nature, early communities relied on shamans—charismatic spiritual figures who dressed in animal skins, feathers, and horns to channel animal spirits.

  • Cave paintings depict human figures wearing bird masks, guiding animal herds from the spirit world back into physical reality.
  • Therianthropes (Human-Animal Hybrids): Magnificent figures combining human limbs with animal heads (such as the Lion-Man of Hohlenstein-Stadel or the Sorcerer of Les Trois-Frères) depict the shaman in an ecstatic ritual state, transcending the human ego to embody the predator's acute senses and power.

B. The Paleolithic Reversal: Cherishing Atypical Individuals

Drawing upon David Graeber and David Wengrow's The Dawn of Everything, Prof. Jiang highlights a remarkable moral fact revealed by physical anthropology: Upper Paleolithic hunter-gatherers deeply cherished individuals with severe physical deformities.

Archaeological Burial Site Physical Skeletal Pathology Mortuary Treatment & Nutritional Care Sociological Meaning
Romito Cave (Calabria, Italy) Young adult male suffering from severe dwarfism (acondroplasia); incapable of hunting or physical labor. Bone chemistry proves he ate the exact same high-quality meat diet as the best hunters; granted a lavish ceremonial burial beneath rock carvings of an aurochs. Human worth was completely decoupled from physical economic productivity.
Sungir (Russia, ~34,000 BP) Adolescents suffering from debilitating physical deformities and twisted spines. Adorned with over 13,000 hand-carved mammoth ivory beads, ivory lances, and fox teeth—the richest prehistoric burials discovered. Physical difference was revered as a sign of divine spiritual selection.

Prof. Jiang asks: In an unforgiving Ice Age where survival was precarious, why did human bands expend precious resources to feed, protect, and lavishly bury individuals who could not hunt?

  • In a modern market framework, an individual's worth is measured by economic utility.
  • In the Paleolithic sacred framework, an individual with a physical abnormality or atypical mind was viewed as more special, not less special.
  • Physical difference indicated that the Mother Goddess had endowed the individual with unique perceptual faculties. Freed from physical hunting, these individuals dedicated their lives to contemplation, meditation, and ritual, serving as the community's shamans, seers, and artists.
graph TD
    Atypical["Physical Atypicality / Severe Disability<br/>(e.g., Dwarfism at Romito Cave)"] --> NonHunter["Incapable of Conventional Physical Hunting"]
    NonHunter --> CommunitySupport["Cherished & Fed Highest Quality Diet by Tribe"]
    CommunitySupport --> SacredVocation["Interpreted as Divine Spiritual Selection"]
    SacredVocation --> ShamanicRole["Dedicated to Meditation, Cosmic Vision & Cave Art"]
    ShamanicRole --> LavishBurial["Honored in Death with Elaborate Funerary Rites"]

6. Geometric Signs: Proto-Writing and Shamanic Trances

Beyond figurative animal art, cave walls across the globe are inscribed with abstract geometric symbols:

  • Canadian paleoanthropologist Genevieve von Petzinger surveyed hundreds of Ice Age caves across Europe and discovered that across 30,000 years of prehistoric art, humans repeatedly used only 32 specific geometric signs (hands, spirals, quadrangles, circles, zigzags, asterisks).
  • These signs represent humanity's earliest proto-writing system, demonstrating that symbolic language existed 25,000 years before Mesopotamian cuneiform.

Prof. Jiang outlines three complementary explanations for these signs:

  1. Visualizing Abstract Concepts: Prehistoric humans could easily paint a horse, but they could not visually draw abstract ideas like harmony, cyclical time, vital energy, or cosmic balance. Geometric signs functioned as visual symbols communicating complex metaphysical mythologies.
  2. The Language of the Spirit World: Entering trances through natural psychedelics, prolonged fasting, or sensory deprivation, shamans perceived entoptic geometric patterns generated by the visual cortex, interpreting them as the sacred script of the gods.
  3. Sacred Mystery: By employing esoteric symbols, shamans preserved the sacred mystery of the divine, communicating that spiritual knowledge required deep initiation.

7. Understanding Human Consciousness: Kant, Neuroscience, and Gender

Immanuel Kant and the Cognitive Construction of Reality

Prof. Jiang connects Paleolithic art to the foundational epistemological insights of German philosopher Immanuel Kant:

  • Before Kant, Western philosophy assumed that human beings merely observe an external, objective reality.
  • Kant revolutionized philosophy by arguing that the human mind actively constructs, structures, and projects reality. Fundamental concepts like space and time do not exist as physical objects in nature; they are internal mental categories through which the brain organizes sensory data.
  • Neuroscience Validates Kant: Modern brain science confirms that human perception is an internal projection. Psychedelic plants and meditative trances alter neural processing, projecting alternative geometries and perceptions of reality that early humans interpreted as the spirit world.

The Sacred Primacy of Women in Deep Prehistory

Prof. Jiang highlights the fundamental difference between modern patriarchal societies and prehistoric cultures:

  • Because childbirth was the supreme, unfathomable miracle of existence, women were revered as sacred and divine.
  • Paleolithic society was either thoroughly egalitarian or matrifocal; women enjoyed profound social respect because only women possessed the magical power to bring new life into the world.
  • It was only with the later rise of intensive plow agriculture, militarized private property, and patriarchal warrior conquest that female autonomy was suppressed.

8. Durkheim's Theory of Religion: The Creation of Society

Prof. Jiang synthesizes the lecture by examining French sociologist Émile Durkheim’s seminal work, The Elementary Forms of Religious Life (1912):

"Religion is above all a system of ideas by which men imagine the society of which they are members, and the obscure yet intimate relations they have with it."

flowchart TD
    Chaos["Raw, Fragmented Sensory Data"] --> ReligiousImagination["Collective Religious Imagination<br/>(Shared Symbols, Mythologies & Rituals)"]
    ReligiousImagination --> TransfiguredWorld["Transfigured Sacred World<br/>(Domination of Mind over Senses)"]
    TransfiguredWorld --> CollectiveConsciousness["Collective Consciousness"]
    CollectiveConsciousness --> HumanSociety["Birth of Human Society & Shared Moral Order"]

Durkheim’s Foundational Insights

  1. The Origin of Thought: The greatest service religion rendered to human intellect was constructing the first conceptual framework of relationships and kinship between things in the cosmos. Religion was the direct ancestor of philosophy and natural science.
  2. The Triumph of Mind Over Senses: Humanity became human not by passively reacting to sensory impressions like beasts, but by using the mind to dominate the senses—uniting fragmented observations into an imagined sacred reality.
  3. Collective Consciousness Creates Society: Religion is inherently a collective social phenomenon. Solitary individuals cannot create language, mythology, or culture. When human bands gathered in deep cave cathedrals, their collective emotional excitation generated sacred ideals that bound individuals into a unified community.
  4. Without Religion, No Society: Religion is what allows human beings to communicate, trust one another, and build enduring institutions. Without religion, humanity could never have transcended solitary animal existence to create society.

9. The Polytheist River vs. The Monotheist Pyramid

During the concluding discussion, Prof. Jiang contrasts ancient animism with modern monotheism:

Dimension of Worldview Ancient Paleolithic Animism Modern Monotheism
Structural Architecture The Circular River: An egalitarian, cyclical flow of birth, death, and rebirth where all living things participate equally. The Hierarchical Pyramid: A rigid, top-down power structure with a singular supreme male God at the apex commanding human subordinates.
Conception of Power No cosmic hierarchy; stars, trees, animals, and humans are diverse, equal spiritual entities. Centralized absolute authority; rigid divine law, dogma, and clerical gatekeepers.
Definition of Cosmic Sin Defying natural balance: killing animals without ritual apology, committing incest, disrupting seasonal harmony. Disobeying divine commandments or questioning institutional ecclesiastical orthodoxy.
Sacred Portals in Nature Caves (nature's womb), mountaintops (Göbekli Tepe), and flowing rivers. Man-made institutional basilicas, churches, and cathedrals.

10. Master Synthesis: The Evolution of Early Human Consciousness

Analytical Lens Upper Paleolithic Cave Artists (c. 35,000 BCE) Sedentary Cultic Settlements (c. 9500 BCE) Modern Materialist Paradigm (21st Century)
Primary Self-Conception Homo religiosus: Children of the Mother Goddess living in animist reciprocity with nature. Sedentary devotees maintaining ancestor skull cults and seasonal cosmological clocks. Homo economicus: Rational utility-maximizing agents driven by career, wealth, and genetics.
Sacred Locus Subterranean cave cathedrals with maximum acoustic resonance. Monumental megaliths (Göbekli Tepe) and domestic living rooms (Çatalhöyük). Disenchanted secular spaces; private individual conscience or skepticism.
View of Atypical Individuals Revere atypicality as divine spiritual endowment; care for disabled as shamans. Domestic integration; ancestral skulls venerated equally in hearths. Medicalized pathology; economic productivity used as primary metric of social value.
Artistic Function Ritual technology; acoustic backdrops for musical communion with animal spirits. Monumental stone reliefs channeling predatory power and cosmological time. Aesthetic commodities exhibited in silent secular museums or sold at auctions.
Epistemological Basis Shamanic visionary intuition; entoptic geometric signs; dreaming. Astronomical observation; animal husbandry; ancestral transmission. Empirical experimental science; mathematical modeling; technological control.

11. Key Civilizational Takeaways

  1. Humanity as Homo Religiosus: Humans are neither purely economic animals (Marx) nor biological machines (Darwin); humanity is first and foremost a religious species defined by the search for cosmic meaning.
  2. Caves as Humanity's First Cathedrals: Early humans never lived in deep caves; they journeyed into subterranean depths with optimal acoustic resonance to conduct musical, torchlit shamanic rituals.
  3. The Cosmic Symmetry of Portals: The maternal womb was viewed as the portal bringing souls from the spirit realm into physical life; burial in the earth was the symmetrical portal returning souls to the cosmos.
  4. Animist Kinship and Scientific Ecology: Animism recognized all living beings as kin with souls. Modern ecology confirms this intuition through discoveries like subterranean fungal networks (the wood wide web).
  5. Moral Hunting and Spiritual Reciprocity: Hunting was not an act of dominion, but a necessary disruption of cosmic balance requiring ritual apologies and shamanic ceremonies to summon animal souls back.
  6. The Paleolithic Reversal of Disability: Prehistoric hunter-gatherers lavishly cared for individuals with severe physical deformities, interpreting bodily difference as a sign of spiritual giftedness suitable for shamans.
  7. Geometric Signs as Proto-Writing: The 32 recurring geometric symbols documented across Ice Age caves represent humanity's first abstract writing system, preceding Sumerian cuneiform by 25,000 years.
  8. Durkheim’s Social Law: Religion is the collective consciousness through which humans imagine society; without shared sacred ideals, human cooperation and culture are impossible.

12. Seminar Discussion Questions

  1. How does Prof. Jiang challenge the Marxist (economic) and Darwinian (biological) definitions of human nature? Why does he argue that humanity is fundamentally Homo religiosus?
  2. Why were Upper Paleolithic cave paintings located exclusively in the deepest, most acoustically resonant chambers of subterranean caverns rather than at sunny cave entrances?
  3. Explain the cosmological symmetry between the mother's womb, the subterranean cave, and earth burial in Paleolithic thought. How did this framework explain the cycle of life and death?
  4. How does modern botanical research regarding fungal networks (mycorrhizae) validate the ancient hunter-gatherer intuition of animism?
  5. Why did Ice Age foragers provide the highest quality food and lavish mortuary honors to individuals suffering from severe physical deformities (such as the dwarf at Romito Cave)?
  6. Analyze Émile Durkheim’s assertion that religion is 'the system of ideas by which men imagine society.' How did prehistoric religion enable the human mind to triumph over raw sensory chaos?

13. Academic & Primary Source References

  • Durkheim, Émile. The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. Translated by Karen E. Fields. New York: Free Press, 1995 (Orig. pub. 1912).
  • Kant, Immanuel. Critique of Pure Reason. Translated by Paul Guyer and Allen W. Wood. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998 (Orig. pub. 1781).
  • Graeber, David, and David Wengrow. The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2021.
  • Von Petzinger, Genevieve. The First Signs: Unlocking the Mysteries of the World's Oldest Symbols. New York: Atria Books, 2016.
  • Lewis-Williams, David. The Mind in the Cave: Consciousness and the Origins of Art. London: Thames & Hudson, 2002.
  • Clottes, Jean. Cave Art. London: Phaidon Press, 2008.
  • Simard, Suzanne. Finding the Mother Tree: Discovering the Wisdom of the Forest. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2021.
  • Reznikoff, Iégor. "Sound Resonance in Prehistoric Painted Caves and Rocks." The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 123, no. 5 (2008): 3603.